Skip to content
Are Compost Bins Worth It? Transform Your Waste into Black Gold

Are Compost Bins Worth It? Transform Your Waste into Black Gold


Did you ever ask yourself what happens to all the kitchen scraps and garden waste you throw away? Think of fruit peelings, old vegetables, and lawn clippings.

Growing up, I used to wonder about this all the time, especially when I saw my parents diligently collecting these scraps. As I grew up I discovered the magic of composting – turning waste into rich, fertile compost for our garden.

If you’re curious about whether compost bins are worth it, you’ve come to the right place. In this blog post, I'll share the benefits of composting, how it has helped my family, and why buying a compost bin could be one of the best decisions you make for your garden and the environment.

The Magic of Composting

Before we get into the question at hand, "Are compost bins worth it?", let me give you a simple overview of the composting process. Composting is like nature’s recycling system, the art of turning organic materials that we often aimlessly throw out as garbage – think food scraps, coffee grounds, and lawn clippings – into something extraordinary.

That's right! We're talking about that rich, earthy substance often hailed as 'black gold', a fertiliser that's close to, if not the best thing you can provide your garden. So, don't rush to throw away what you once though as 'waste'; repurpose it instead. Composting offers a path to greater resourcefulness, less waste, and a reduced environmental impact, while also promoting healthier gardens.


How Does a Compost Bin Work?

Now that we've got the basics of composting down, lets take a look at the role of the compost bin.

A compost bin provides a controlled environment for the composting process to occur. By maintaining the right balance of greens (nitrogen-rich materials like food scraps) and browns (carbon-rich materials like leaves), along with moisture and air, we can speed up the decomposition process. This is how we get our highly sought-after 'black gold', chock full of beneficial nutrients for our gardens.

My Composting Journey

I remember when I first started composting, nearly 5 years ago. I gathered up all those kitchen scraps - banana peels, coffee grounds, eggshells - and tossed them into a compost pile I set up in the corner of my yard, heaped in some fallen leaves I had raked up and that was it, my composting journey had begun.

I must admit, it took quite a while to witness my compost pile undergo its transformation, but when I finally harvested that first batch of compost—dark, rich, and oh-so-smelly—I couldn't help but feel a rush of pride. I couldn't wait to put my compost to work, so I immediately started digging shovelfuls into every garden bed and pot I could find. What happened over the next few weeks was nothing short of remarkable.

My tomato plants shot up like skyscrapers and produced larger and more vibrant fruit than I had ever seen before. I noticed a similar change with my herbs; all of a sudden, they were fuller and bushier than before, and you could smell them just by walking by!

It wasn't just about gardening anymore; it was like I was part of this incredible cycle of life and growth, right in my own backyard.

Benefits of Using a Compost Bin

Enrich Your Soil

Compost is often referred to as "black gold" because of its ability to improve soil structure, add nutrients, and increase moisture retention. Plants thrive in compost-rich soil, which means a more vibrant and productive garden.

Controlling what goes into the compost is key to ensuring its quality and, ultimately, what comes out. I feel better knowing there are no unwanted chemicals or additives going into my garden when I use compost that I've carefully crafted from organic materials in my own backyard.

Reduce Waste

One of the most compelling reasons for me to use a compost bin is the significant reduction in waste. According to this article by Clean Up Australia

"Over 7.3 million tonnes of food is wasted in Australia every year - which equates to nearly 300kgs of food per person per year."

By composting, I can divert this waste from landfills, reducing my carbon footprint and contributing to a healthier planet.


Save Money

By creating my own compost, I can save money on commercial fertilisers and soil amendments. Plus, since I grow my own vegetables, the improved soil leads to better yields, saving me even more money on groceries. It's a win-win situation!

Family Time and Learning

One of the most rewarding aspects of composting for me has been spending time with my family outdoors. Each day, my son and I gather kitchen scraps and yard waste, and together we turn the compost bin.

It's become a cherished family activity, teaching my son about sustainability and the cycle of nature. Seeing his excitement as he watches how our efforts transform waste into rich, fertile compost has been priceless.

Not only are we nurturing our garden, but we’re also strengthening our family bond and our understanding of the environment.

How Effective Are Compost Bins?

Speed and Efficiency

One of the biggest advantages of using a compost bin is the speed and efficiency of the composting process. Compost bins create an optimal environment for microorganisms to break down organic matter quickly.

By controlling factors like aeration, moisture, and the balance of green and brown materials, compost bins can produce usable compost in a matter of months, compared to open compost piles that can take a year or more.

Quality of Compost

Compost bins help produce high-quality compost by maintaining consistent conditions. The enclosed space protects the compost from pests and extreme weather, ensuring a more uniform breakdown of materials.

This results in nutrient-rich compost that is ideal for enriching garden soil and boosting plant growth.


The Results Speak

Once the composting bug bit me, I began researching ways to improve the process. While the compost pile was cheap and easy, it took longer than I would have liked to produce usable compost.

Another significant reason I shifted away from the pile was due to the smell. Let me tell you, those things are smelly! Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. And unless you have a large property or backyard, you don't want those odors wafting through your house. Your neighbors won't appreciate it either.

Naturally, a compost bin was the solution to this problem, easily one of the best investments I've made for my garden. The transition to a compost bin not only addressed the odor issue but also made the composting process more efficient. With pests unable to infiltrate and the contents contained within the tumbler, managing the compost became much simpler. Tasks such as aerating and turning the compost became noticeably easier overnight.

What's more, the decomposition process kicked into high gear, not only improving the quality of the compost but also reducing the time it took to become usable. It emerged darker, more crumbly, and bursting with nutrients, outperforming the results of the open pile I had initially experimented with.

While the compost pile gets the job done, if you're pressed for space or time, investing in a compost bin is highly recommended! The difference it made in the efficiency and quality of my composting experience was truly game-changing.

How Long Does It Take for a Compost Bin to Start Working?

Initial Decomposition

The time it takes for a compost bin to start working can vary based on several factors, including the materials used, the size of the bin, and how often you turn the compost.

Typically, you can expect to see the initial stages of decomposition within a few weeks. This is when the materials start to break down and heat up, indicating that microbial activity is occurring.


Useable Compost

For the compost to become fully mature and ready for use in your garden, it generally takes about three to six months.

This timeline can be shorter if you use a compost tumbler, which speeds up the process through regular turning and aeration.

Regularly monitoring the moisture and balance of greens and browns will also help speed up the process.

Patience Pays Off

When I first started using a compost bin, I was eager to see results. While the initial decomposition started within a month, it took about 3-4 months for me to get rich, usable compost. Still a far cry better than the 8 or so months it took for my old compost pile to do the same job.

The wait was worth it, though, as I've said throughout this article, the quality of the compost was significantly improved.

Practical Tips for Composting Success

Choosing the Right Compost Bin

There are various types of compost bins available, from simple DIY setups to advanced tumblers. Consider your space, budget, and how much organic waste you produce when choosing a bin.

Finding the Perfect Spot

Where you put your compost bin can make a big difference in how well it works. Plus, the type of bin you have will help decide the best surface for it. Some quick tips:

  • Keep it accessible
  • Ensure it has good drainage
  • Find a spot with a balance of sun and shade.

Wondering where to put your compost bin? Check out this article, where we go into more detail on finding the perfect place for your compost bin.

Balancing Greens and Browns

Maintaining the right balance of greens and browns is crucial. Greens include kitchen scraps like vegetable peels and coffee grounds, while browns include leaves, straw, and cardboard.

According to the University of New Hampshire, "Composting is most effective when there are 30 parts brown to every 1 part green".

You can read more about achieving the optimal 'green to brown ratio' in their article 'Composting for the Home Gardener'.


Turning and Aeration

Turning your compost pile regularly introduces air, which speeds up the decomposition process. Use a garden fork or a compost tumbler to mix the contents every week or so.

Managing Moisture

Your compost should be as moist as a wrung-out sponge. Too dry, and the decomposition will slow down; too wet, and it might start to smell. Adjust by adding more browns or greens as needed.


During my first year of composting, I encountered common issues like bad smells and slow decomposition. I learned that these were often due to imbalances in the compost mix or lack of aeration. Through trial and error, I found the right balance and now enjoy a smooth composting process.

Embrace the Composting Journey

So, are compost bins worth it? In my humble opinion, absolutely! They offer a multitude of benefits, from reducing waste and enriching your soil to saving money and fostering a deeper connection with nature.

Composting is a simple yet powerful way to make a positive impact on your garden and the environment.

Start your composting journey today. You’ll not only transform your waste into valuable compost but also experience the joy and satisfaction that comes from nurturing your own garden.

Do you have any composting tips or stories to share? I’d love to hear them in the comments below. Let’s grow greener together, and as always, Happy Gardening!

Previous article Where is the Best Place to Put a Compost Bin? Finding the Perfect Spot!

Leave a comment

* Required fields